This is pretty much how I see it, minus the David Foster Wallace bit.

The Skeptical 1L

-- By CarlaChow - 16 Feb 2012

Awareness

Law School as Imagination Test

In my limited experience thus far, law school (and the Big Firm lifestyle it seems to promote), as much as anything in the world, enforces the so-called ‘default setting’. In its first semester it serves up a fixed set of courses, a fixed set of principles and definitions, and a seemingly fixed set of career options. We are given a singular ideal of success promising extraordinary wealth and physical comforts built upon a tried and true formula that cannot be questioned or changed. To see grades not as a limiting force or law school as an imagination test thus seems, at best, unrealistic or idealistic and, at worst, a blatant lie told to calm those who have already been barred from attaining this ideal of success. This skepticism is to be expected and obviously why almost no one shows up/everybody fails the real test.

I am, generally speaking, a pragmatist. Echoing Cohen I believe that it is not enough to talk about what something is or what it is called but that one should focus on what something actually does. This is especially true when trying to convince the skeptical 1L who, unlike Holmes’ bad man, is not only self-interested but is often also either self-righteous or defensive about this self-interest, claiming that she has been forced into this position of self-interestedness by outside circumstances. Thus, it is not enough to talk about personal freedom and unfettered thinking; one must talk about results and, more specifically, how those results affect the skeptical 1L and her circumstances.

Like the law, this type of thinking does not carry with it a moral judgment. It is not virtuous in and of itself and one should not do it simply because it is Good in some inherent way. Likewise, it would be difficult to say that doing Big Firm work is inherently Bad. Instead what we have seen is that consciously deciding what does and does not have meaning allows one to think creatively about what the law is, what it does, how it works, how it should work, and how it knows things. The skeptical 1L dutifully accepts these principles while still clinging to the larger default paradigm. She sees no reason to abandon it as the former are interesting thought exercises but ultimately have little to no effect on her career, her need to repay her student loans, etc. This is of course a tautological fallacy. They only have no effect if she subscribes to the belief that the tried and true formula leading to extraordinary wealth and physical comforts is the only way to be successful.

And here is the not so well kept but surprisingly well ignored secret: the tried and true formula does not work or will not work for much longer. Almost everyone recognizes that the legal market is in crisis and undergoing substantial restructuring which will not disappear with an economic recovery. It is equally obvious to people that the ideal of success we are grasping at is not what it once was. It is becoming more and more difficult to attain and, perhaps more importantly, less and less desirable a lifestyle.

So, the ship is sinking and we are clinging to floating debris instead of trying to change boats. This is where law school can and should play a pivotal role in changing the rules of the game. By challenging students to think creatively, a thought exercise in how judges should rule could translate into how they actually do rule. To engage in this type of thinking is to eschew with any preconceived notions and the skeptical 1L may finally be able to arrive at what it is she actually wants to achieve and in what she wants to believe. The ideal of success is not a predetermined bundle package. Now perhaps more than ever the legal world is waiting to be built and shaped. Suddenly, the skeptical, self-interested 1L finds herself suddenly a part of something much larger than herself and her career. With it she finds the power to change the world, to choose what is important and what is not – a power she had all along.

This is Water

• #Set ALLOWTOPICVIEW = TWikiAdminGroup, CarlaChow
• #Set DENYTOPICVIEW = TWikiGuest

Note: TWiki has strict formatting rules for preference declarations. Make sure you preserve the three spaces, asterisk, and extra space at the beginning of these lines. If you wish to give access to any other users simply add them to the comma separated ALLOWTOPICVIEW list.